At the car repair shop, we often hear mechanics mention gear oil and transmission fluid when discussing any fix involving the gearbox — so much so that many might have started to believe that they are the same. But in reality, gear oil is very different from transmission fluid, and the two are not interchangeable.
Advertisement
The term “gear oil” is actually broad, as it applies to various lubricants used in different vehicle systems. The most common is manual transmission fluid (MTF), which lubricates the gears in a manual transmission to ensure smooth shifting. This gear oil also comes in different types, so choosing the right MTF for your vehicle can be daunting but very important.
Another type is differential oil, which ensures the gears inside a vehicle’s differential function correctly. This is crucial when turning since the wheels on each side of the vehicle need to rotate at different speeds. Four-wheel drive vehicles require another type of gear oil, transfer case fluid, to lubricate the components that send power to all four wheels.
Advertisement
Gear oil is formulated specifically for heavy-duty metal-on-metal contact within a manual transmission. Each type is uniquely formulated to handle specific pressures, temperatures, and stress levels within the drivetrain. To put it simply, think of gear oil as a protective cushion, then imagine gears in a car as metal cogs constantly grinding against each other. Without proper lubrication, they would wear out quickly due to friction and heat. Gear oil coats these gears with a thick film to prevent direct contact.
How is gear oil different from transmission fluid?
Though often confused, gear oil and transmission fluid are not the same. They differ in function, viscosity, and chemical composition. Gear oil is mainly used in manual transmissions, while transmission fluid is specifically designed for automatic transmissions, which works differently.
Advertisement
For faster distinction, think of them as different cooking oil types. Gear oil is like thick, high-heat frying oil, designed to withstand intense pressure and prevent metal components from grinding together. Transmission fluid, on the other hand, is more like a light, smooth vegetable oil, flowing freely to ensure seamless operation in an automatic transmission, where hydraulic power is used to shift gears instead of direct mechanical engagement.
Since gear oil is thicker and more viscous, it is ideal for high-pressure applications. It is often labeled with viscosity grades like 75W-90, where the first number represents its flow in cold temperatures, and the second indicates its thickness in heat. Higher numbers mean thicker oil, providing better protection for gears under extreme stress. In contrast, automatic transmission fluid (ATF) is much thinner for quick and efficient shifting.
Advertisement
ATF also contains special additives for cooling, cleaning, and enhanced performance within the transmission. Different types of ATF contain varying additives. Transmission fluids can be ranked from worst to best based on their composition, performance, and popularity. However, ranking should not be the basis for choosing an ATF. Your car’s manual usually indicates the specific ATF best suited for your vehicle. That’s because using the wrong fluid can damage your transmission.
